inicio mail me! sindicaci;ón

Where oh where does my profile reside?

by Kathleen Gilroy

[cross posted on and Future of Communities]


In the past couple of days I have had conversations with two people representing different enterprise 2.0 services (
iUpload and ConnectBeam) about managing the online profile. In thinking about building second generation web communities, I have come to believe that the online profile is at the heart the new web. In the search economy, you need a dynamic digital identity. It is the means by which the right people find you and then connect with you. But in the world of web services, where oh where does my profile live? I know have mini profiles all over the place: I started with my blog and added a profile on Linked In. I thought Linked In might provide me with a good home for my profile but when the fee for service elements were added to Linked In, the really useful aspects of hosting my profile there were lost — people can’t find me unless they pay for a higher level of service. I’ve got mini profiles on Flickr and del.icio.us but they can’t act as profile central. And I’ve just added a new profile to our new Otter Networks service which is built on iUpload and Netvibes.

What I need is a place for my profile that can be plugged into any web service I join. And by plugged in I mean can dynamically draw text, bookmarks, images, and videos from all of these services and build them into a dynamic view of what’s going on now. And I’m not dealing with the issue of residing “inside” an enterprise.

I’ve been interviewing people for a paper and podcast series on new communities and when I ask them about profiles, this is what I hear:

We connect into Active Directory but that is primarily for authority and authentication. We recommend that you build a rich profile on our service and at some point in the future we will integrate this rich profiling back into the enterprise directories.

Is this really how it is going to go? When and how will these things be integrated in a way that really does provide me with a rich, dynamic digital identity that can cross web services as I move in and out of communities of interest and practice?

Share and Enjoy:
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Print this article!
  • TwitThis
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
  • Digg
  • Google
  • StumbleUpon
  • SphereIt


2 Comments »

Niall CookJanuary 26th, 2007 at 11:11 am

Surely is this new, distributed world your profile resides everywhere, not in a single place where it can be managed.

Instead, what is required are tools that allow us to aggregate our online selves – wherever that might be and whatever form it may take.

Tom MandelJanuary 29th, 2007 at 12:00 pm

(I’ve blogged this at http://www.tommandel.com/blog/)

Niall – and Kathleen too – lets not confuse “identity” and “profile.”

With or without the Web, I have profiles in many many places; people always have had. A profile (think of the metaphor behind the word) is a particular view of who I am created for a particular purpose. The description of me on the jacket of one of my books, like the description of me at http://www.connectbeam.com, is a single instance description. I met Kathleen Gilroy last week for the first time (and not face to face); if someone asks her about me next week, she’ll have something to say — that too is a ‘profile.’

Even – and maybe moreso! – the word identity is subject to this problematic use online. People write about the subject as if before the Web ‘identity’ was a simple thing! Not just my profile, but *who I am* changes depending on when and from where someone looks at “me.” And the question of *where* my identity lives on the Web seems equally confused. In the everyday world before the Web, there was no one place my identity lived; there still isn’t. My identity is who I am; it lives in me and in my acts and nowhere else.

» Subscribe to the RSS feed for these comments

Your comment

Want an image to appear near your comment? Go to gravatar.com

HTML-Tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Additional comments powered by BackType